Why is some whisky peated? Where the smoke comes from, with a peat dial
Some whisky tastes of bonfires and sea air because the barley was dried over a peat fire. The number on the label, the ppm, is measured in the malt and not in the bottle.
Drag the dial to see how a peat level, the cut at the still and time in the cask change how much smoke is left in the glass.

Some whisky tastes of hospital corridors, bonfires and sea air. Most does not. The difference is not the water or the barrel. It is what happened to the barley before it ever met a still: whether it was dried over a peat fire.
Where the smoke comes from
To make malt whisky, barley is soaked and allowed to sprout, which turns its starch into sugar the yeast can eat. Before the sprouts use up all that sugar, the maltster stops the process by drying the grain in a kiln. That is the moment peat comes in. Peat is compacted plant matter cut from bogs, and when it smoulders it makes thick smoke. If a peat fire is lit under the damp barley at the start of kilning, smoke compounds stick to the wet grain. Dry the barley over a fire of something else, or with plain hot air, and none of that happens.
The smoke compounds are called phenols: phenol itself, cresols, guaiacol and a family of relatives. Between them they give the medicinal, tarry, smoky, bacon-and-seaweed notes people associate with Islay whisky. Smoke from a hotter fire tends to carry different proportions of these compounds than a cooler one, which is one reason two peated whiskies at the same number can still taste different.
What the number on the bottle means
Peat level is quoted in ppm, parts per million of phenols. The detail that trips most people up: it is measured in the malted barley as it arrives at the distillery, not in the whisky in your glass. Some well-known examples quoted by writers: Lagavulin 16 is around 35 ppm, and the Octomore 7.1 was peated to 208 ppm. An unpeated malt sits near zero.
After the barley, the phenols have a long way to go. They have to survive mashing and fermentation, then travel through two distillations. Phenols come off the still late, toward the end of the run, so where the distiller decides to start collecting the good spirit and where to stop (the "cut") changes how much is captured. A lot is left behind in the leftovers. New spirit typically carries far less phenol than the barley it came from, with figures of roughly 30–70% less quoted, and maturing in a cask takes more away again. A high number on the malt does not automatically mean a louder glass.
Drag the dial and you will see the point: even at 35 ppm, what ends up in the bottle is a small fraction of the malt figure. Yet a 35 ppm whisky does not taste like a tenth of a smoke machine. Smoke phenols are strong aromas, and noses pick them up at very low levels.
Why smoky is not the same as peaty
Peat is one source of smoke flavour. A cask that was charred, or a whisky finished in a smoked cask, can taste smoky with no peat in the malt at all. Peat flavour also depends on which phenols it carries: some lean medicinal and briny, others sweeter and more woody. That is why a lighter Highland smoke and a coastal Islay malt can be told apart even when the numbers are not far apart. Treat ppm as a rough guide to how much smoke went in, not a score for how smoky the dram will taste.
The number describes the barley. The glass describes everything that happened after.
How to try it without a big spend
Pick a style, not a brand: a lightly peated Highland or island malt first, then an Islay malt, tasted side by side, with a little water in the glass. A few drops of water often opens the smoke up. Sip slowly, and as always, keep it to a sensible amount and never drink and drive. If you want the smoke without the alcohol, a smoked tea such as lapsang souchong carries some of the same phenol notes, made with pinewood smoke rather than peat.
Whatever you choose, read the label with this in mind: a peat number tells you what the maltster did, and the rest is up to the still, the cask and your nose.